You know those bands who used to be a big deal, but now the only original member left is the bass player, and he’s out there playing the same old hits at state fairs with a bunch of new guys, pretending like it’s still 1979? I have always gotten the same vibe from the resurrection of the VW Beetle in the late ’90s. The “New Beetle” looks the part, and it’s a better car in a lot of ways, but does it really count as a Beetle? Or would you rather just have an original?
There was no doubt yesterday about which car you preferred. AI-enhanced photos or not, the little blue Honda Civic absolutely dominated the poll. Old Hondas just have that effect on a lot of us. Some of you even admitted that the Suzuki Swift is probably a better car, but chose the Honda anyway.
I’m going to go the other way. It’s not that I dislike the Civic; quite the opposite. It’s a well-preserved little gem of a car. But the Swift (and its lesser sibling the Geo Metro) hold a special place in my heart. They’re plucky. They’ve got heart. And they’re tough little bastards. If ever a movie were made about the Swift and Metro, the car would be played by Sean Astin.

When it comes to some cars, the basic design is simply set in stone. After the Probe debacle, the Ford Mustang was never going to be anything other than a front-engine, rear-wheel-drive coupe. (No, the Mach-E doesn’t count.) And the Corvette simply must have a V8 and only two seats. Often, this carries over to revival models too; the newer Mini models have the same transverse engine and FWD layout as the original. But when Volkswagen introduced the New Beetle in 1998, it was absolutely nothing like the original. These two cars have the same name and a similar silhouette, but everything else about them is different: engine placement, driven wheels, engine cooling, even cylinder count. The new one has a lot of stuff the old one doesn’t, especially when it comes to safety features and comfort and convenience, but has it lost the charm that made the original so popular? Let’s take a look at one example of each, and see.
1974 Volkswagen Super Beetle – $3,600

Engine/drivetrain: 1.6-liter OHV flat-4, four-speed manual, RWD
Location: Portland, OR
Odometer reading: 105,000 miles (might not be accurate)
Operational status: Runs and drives well
The VW Beetle is almost certainly the most recognizable car on the planet. I’ve never met anyone, gearhead or not, who couldn’t identify a Beetle when they saw one. Ask a kid to draw one, and you’ll get a reasonable facsimile of the rough outline. VW built more than twenty million of these things, an almost unimaginable number, and a surprising number of them are still around. Whole cottage industries exist solely because of this car. Not all Beetles were created equal, however; this is the later model 1303, or “Super Beetle,” which has a bunch of improvements including a whole new front suspension that didn’t take up half the trunk space in the front. It also has a curved windshield, the most distinctive change to the Beetle’s styling in its long history.

The Super Beetle also came with a little bit bigger engine than the standard Beetle, displacing 1600 cubic centimeters. It’s still air-cooled, of course, and still makes that characteristic Beetle sound. This one runs and drives well, the seller says, but they don’t go into much detail. The speedometer cable is broken, so we can’t be sure how many miles are actually on it, but does it really matter?

This is the only view we get of the interior, but it looks all right. The seller does say the base of the rear seat is missing, but I’m sure replacements are available somewhere. If the day ever comes that you can’t find restoration parts for a Beetle, we’re truly in trouble.

This car looks really familiar to me; it’s almost the twin of the Super Beetle I owned for a hot minute back in 1992. This one is in significantly better shape, though. It had better be; it’s almost ten times the price. It has some primer on it; someone has been doing some repair work to it. I don’t know what it’s like underneath, but the seller says it’s “pretty solid.” The front bumper is missing, but personally, I like Beetles with no bumpers. I’d probably take the rear bumper off too.
2006 Volkswagen New Beetle – $2,950

Engine/drivetrain: 2.5-liter DOHC inline-5, five-speed manual, FWD
Location: Portland, OR
Odometer reading: 130,000 miles
Operational status: Runs and drives well
As long-lived as the Beetle was, nothing lasts forever, and in the 1970s VW phased out the Beetle in favor of the new front-wheel-drive, water-cooled Rabbit. Or Golf, to the rest of the world. The Golf’s layout took over the rest of Volkswagen’s lineup; only the Vanagon stuck with the old rear-engine design, and it was discontinued in the US after 1991. It made sense, then, when the New Beetle was designed, to base it on the Golf.

The New Beetle came out in 1998, and it was facelifted for 2006, with some interior and exterior tweaks as well as a new base engine, a 2.5 liter inline five-cylinder. It gives the Beetle a nice bump in power, and by most accounts, is just as reliable as the old “two-point-slow” engine. It has a weird timing chain design that makes it a pain to replace if it goes bad, but from what I gather, that’s not a common occurrence. This one runs and drives well, and the seller claims it has been well-maintained, but it’s a dealership, so take that with a grain of salt.

The interior looks decent, but the dashboard has that grubby look that this era of Volkswagens seem to get when the soft-touch plastics start to wear out. What was wrong with regular old hard plastics, I’ll never know. Everything looks intact, though, including the all-important flower vase next to the steering wheel. The seller does say that the airbag warning light is on, which is something you should probably have looked at.

The outside looks good, and if it has been a Pacific Northwest car all along, it shouldn’t have much if any rust. The only thing that concerns me is that it has three alloy wheels and one steel wheel. It could just be the spare; VW made a big deal of including a full-size spare in its cars, but better check the trunk and make sure the fourth alloy wheel is back there.
These two are competing for different buyers, I realize, and that will affect how you vote. The Super Beetle may be reliable, but any car that old is really more of a hobby car at this point, rather than viable daily transportation. The New Beetle could make a good inexpensive beater, or a first car for a teenager, once you figure out why the airbag light is on. What do you think? Are you going for the new and improved version, or sticking with the old original?
The post Which Bug Would You Rather Catch? 1974 VW Super Beetle vs 2006 VW Beetle appeared first on The Autopian.